Hi @tyler.andreasen,
I have just checked your tenant and found that you have enabled one or more Custom HTML pages, which, when enabled, overrides the New Universal Login experience. There should be a yellow warning banner letting you know about this as well.
In this situation, please make sure that you have disabled the Customize Login Page, Customize Password Reset Page, and Customize MFA Page toggles on your Universal Login Experience settings.
See New Universal Login Page Overrides with Custom HTML for more details.
Please let us know if you have any issues with this.
Thanks,
Rueben