"Import users to Auth0" not working coming from a custom database (mysql)

Having issues with the “Import users to auth0” setting in my database connection. I have a js webapp that connects to auth0 fine, also connects to my AWS RDS MySql database just fine but doesn’t work when I turn on the ability to import users to Auth0 to do the lazy migration. I get the following in the logs, everything works except it never logs me in or creates the user in auth0. If I turn off the setting it will log the user in after validating the DB and create the account in Auth0. Not sure what the issue is as I followed everything in the docs.

10:21:01 AM:
 Connecting to the database...
10:21:01 AM:
 Executing query: SELECT id, nickname, email, password FROM users WHERE email = ?
10:21:01 AM:
 Connected to the database
10:21:02 AM:
 Query executed successfully
10:21:02 AM:
 User found: myusername@mail.com
10:21:02 AM:
 finished webtask request
10:21:02 AM:
 Database connection closed